Paper Mill Playhouse Tickets
  1. Gametime
  2. New York City

Paper Mill Playhouse Events

Never miss a beat

Sign up or log in to track your favorite events, performers, and venues.

Clean white overlay showing multiple favorite cards, each with an image, description lines, and a red heart icon

By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

  • 2/21

    Tmrw

    Come From Away
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    Get Tickets
  • 2/21

    Tmrw

    Come From Away
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $144+
  • 2/22

    Sun

    Come From Away
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $576+
  • 2/22

    Sun

    Come From Away
    7:00 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $674+
  • 2/25

    Wed

    Come From Away
    11:00 AMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    Get Tickets
  • 2/25

    Wed

    Come From Away
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $501+
  • 2/26

    Thu

    Come From Away
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $491+
  • 2/26

    Thu

    Come From Away
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $481+
  • 2/27

    Fri

    Shrek - The Musical Jr
    11:00 AMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    Get Tickets
  • 2/27

    Fri

    Come From Away
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $491+
  • 2/27

    Fri

    Come From Away
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $312+
  • 2/28

    Sat

    Come From Away
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    Get Tickets
  • 2/28

    Sat

    Come From Away
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $429+
  • 3/1

    Sun

    Come From Away
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    Get Tickets
  • 3/1

    Sun

    Come From Away
    7:00 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $154+
  • 5/28

    Thu

    West Side Story
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $171+
  • 5/28

    Thu

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $103+
  • 5/29

    Fri

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $103+
  • 5/30

    Sat

    West Side Story
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $103+
  • 5/30

    Sat

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $103+
  • 5/31

    Sun

    West Side Story
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $114+
  • 5/31

    Sun

    West Side Story
    7:00 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $111+
  • 6/3

    Wed

    West Side Story
    7:00 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $111+
  • 6/4

    Thu

    West Side Story
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $326+
  • 6/4

    Thu

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $114+
  • 6/5

    Fri

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $111+
  • 6/6

    Sat

    West Side Story
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $114+
  • 6/6

    Sat

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $111+
  • 6/7

    Sun

    West Side Story
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $114+
  • 6/7

    Sun

    West Side Story
    7:00 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $111+
  • 6/10

    Wed

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $111+
  • 6/11

    Thu

    West Side Story
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $326+
  • 6/11

    Thu

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $111+
  • 6/12

    Fri

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $111+
  • 6/13

    Sat

    West Side Story
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $160+
  • 6/13

    Sat

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $111+
  • 6/14

    Sun

    West Side Story
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $111+
  • 6/14

    Sun

    West Side Story
    7:00 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $122+
  • 6/17

    Wed

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $111+
  • 6/18

    Thu

    West Side Story
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $215+
  • 6/18

    Thu

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $111+
  • 6/19

    Fri

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $143+
  • 6/20

    Sat

    West Side Story
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $147+
  • 6/20

    Sat

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $111+
  • 6/21

    Sun

    West Side Story
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $111+
  • 6/21

    Sun

    West Side Story
    7:00 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $146+
  • 6/24

    Wed

    West Side Story (13+ Event)
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    Get Tickets
  • 6/24

    Wed

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $111+
  • 6/25

    Thu

    West Side Story
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $111+
  • 6/25

    Thu

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $152+
  • 6/26

    Fri

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $111+
  • 6/27

    Sat

    West Side Story
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $111+
  • 6/27

    Sat

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $147+
  • 6/28

    Sun

    West Side Story
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $147+
  • 6/28

    Sun

    West Side Story
    7:00 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $147+

Verified Tickets at the Best Prices.100% Gametime Guaranteed.

100% Gametime Guaranteed.

  • Lowest Price Guarantee
  • Event Cancellation Protection
  • On-Time Ticket Delivery