Last-minute gift idea 🎁 Send a Gametime Gift Card
SEE ALL CONCERT TICKETS
comedytheater
mlbnbanflnhlmlsncaaother
AlbuquerqueAtlantaAustinBaltimoreBig SkyBirminghamBlacksburgBoiseBostonBuffaloCalgaryCharlotteChicagoCincinnatiClevelandColumbiaColumbusDallasDenverDes MoinesDetroitEdmontonEl PasoFayettevilleFresnoGrand RapidsHartfordHonoluluHoustonIndianapolisInternational EventsJackson/OxfordJacksonville/GainesvilleKansas CityKnoxvilleLas VegasLexingtonLittle RockLos AngelesLouisvilleLubbockMemphisMiamiMilwaukee/Green BayMinneapolisMontrealMorgantownNashvilleNew OrleansNew York CityOklahoma City/TulsaOmahaOrlandoOttawaPhiladelphiaPhoenixPittsburghPortlandProvidenceRaleigh/DurhamReno/TahoeRichmondSacramentoSalt Lake CitySan AntonioSan DiegoSeattleSF Bay AreaSt. LouisSyracuseTallahasseeTampaTorontoTucsonVancouverWashington DCWinnipeg
Paper Mill Playhouse Tickets
  1. Gametime
  2. New York City

Paper Mill Playhouse Events

Added to your Favorites!

  • 12/30

    Tmrw

    Frozen - The Musical
    7:00 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    Get Tickets
  • 1/1/26

    Thu

    Frozen - The Musical
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    Get Tickets
  • 1/1/26

    Thu

    Frozen - The Musical
    7:00 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $194+
  • 1/2/26

    Fri

    Frozen - The Musical
    7:00 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    Get Tickets
  • 1/3/26

    Sat

    Frozen - The Musical
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    Get Tickets
  • 1/3/26

    Sat

    Frozen - The Musical
    7:00 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    Get Tickets
  • 1/4/26

    Sun

    Frozen - The Musical
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $405+
  • 1/4/26

    Sun

    Frozen - The Musical
    7:00 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $103+
  • 1/8/26

    Thu

    Disney's Frozen - The Musical
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $111+
  • 1/10/26

    Sat

    Disney's Frozen
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    Get Tickets
  • 1/11/26

    Sun

    Disney's Frozen
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    Get Tickets
  • 1/11/26

    Sun

    Disney's Frozen
    7:00 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    Get Tickets
  • 2/4/26

    Wed

    Come From Away
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $114+
  • 2/5/26

    Thu

    Come From Away
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    Get Tickets
  • 2/5/26

    Thu

    Come From Away
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $93+
  • 2/6/26

    Fri

    Come From Away
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $93+
  • 2/7/26

    Sat

    Come From Away
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $188+
  • 2/7/26

    Sat

    Come From Away
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $172+
  • 2/8/26

    Sun

    Come From Away
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $138+
  • 2/8/26

    Sun

    Come From Away
    7:00 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $174+
  • 2/11/26

    Wed

    Come From Away
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $93+
  • 2/12/26

    Thu

    Come From Away
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $115+
  • 2/12/26

    Thu

    Come from Away
    7:00 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    Get Tickets
  • 2/12/26

    Thu

    Come From Away
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $138+
  • 2/13/26

    Fri

    Shrek - The Musical Jr
    11:00 AMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    Get Tickets
  • 2/13/26

    Fri

    Come From Away
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $93+
  • 2/14/26

    Sat

    Shrek - The Musical Jr
    11:00 AMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $55+
  • 2/14/26

    Sat

    Come From Away
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $108+
  • 2/14/26

    Sat

    Come From Away
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $114+
  • 2/15/26

    Sun

    Come from Away
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $138+
  • 2/15/26

    Sun

    Come from Away
    2:00 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    Get Tickets
  • 2/15/26

    Sun

    Come From Away
    7:00 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $108+
  • 2/18/26

    Wed

    Come From Away
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $93+
  • 2/19/26

    Thu

    Come From Away
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $208+
  • 2/19/26

    Thu

    Come From Away
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $114+
  • 2/20/26

    Fri

    Come From Away
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $93+
  • 2/21/26

    Sat

    Come From Away
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $93+
  • 2/21/26

    Sat

    Come From Away
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $93+
  • 2/22/26

    Sun

    Come From Away
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $194+
  • 2/22/26

    Sun

    Come From Away
    7:00 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $93+
  • 2/25/26

    Wed

    Come From Away
    11:00 AMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    Get Tickets
  • 2/25/26

    Wed

    Come From Away
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $93+
  • 2/26/26

    Thu

    Come From Away
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $201+
  • 2/26/26

    Thu

    Come From Away
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $93+
  • 2/27/26

    Fri

    Shrek - The Musical Jr
    11:00 AMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    Get Tickets
  • 2/27/26

    Fri

    Come From Away
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $114+
  • 2/28/26

    Sat

    Come From Away
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $138+
  • 2/28/26

    Sat

    Come From Away
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $93+
  • 3/1/26

    Sun

    Come From Away
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $114+
  • 3/1/26

    Sun

    Come From Away
    7:00 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $93+
  • 5/28/26

    Thu

    West Side Story
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    Get Tickets
  • 5/28/26

    Thu

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $108+
  • 5/29/26

    Fri

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $108+
  • 5/30/26

    Sat

    West Side Story
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $117+
  • 5/30/26

    Sat

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $108+
  • 5/31/26

    Sun

    West Side Story
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $108+
  • 5/31/26

    Sun

    West Side Story
    7:00 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $108+
  • 6/3/26

    Wed

    West Side Story
    7:00 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $108+
  • 6/4/26

    Thu

    West Side Story
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    Get Tickets
  • 6/4/26

    Thu

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $155+
  • 6/5/26

    Fri

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $108+
  • 6/6/26

    Sat

    West Side Story
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $108+
  • 6/6/26

    Sat

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $115+
  • 6/7/26

    Sun

    West Side Story
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $115+
  • 6/7/26

    Sun

    West Side Story
    7:00 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $108+
  • 6/10/26

    Wed

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $108+
  • 6/11/26

    Thu

    West Side Story
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    Get Tickets
  • 6/11/26

    Thu

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $108+
  • 6/12/26

    Fri

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $108+
  • 6/13/26

    Sat

    West Side Story
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $115+
  • 6/13/26

    Sat

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $115+
  • 6/14/26

    Sun

    West Side Story
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $108+
  • 6/14/26

    Sun

    West Side Story
    7:00 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $102+
  • 6/17/26

    Wed

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $108+
  • 6/18/26

    Thu

    West Side Story
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $201+
  • 6/18/26

    Thu

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $108+
  • 6/19/26

    Fri

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $108+
  • 6/20/26

    Sat

    West Side Story
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $174+
  • 6/20/26

    Sat

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $108+
  • 6/21/26

    Sun

    West Side Story
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $108+
  • 6/21/26

    Sun

    West Side Story
    7:00 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $141+
  • 6/24/26

    Wed

    West Side Story (13+ Event)
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    Get Tickets
  • 6/24/26

    Wed

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $108+
  • 6/25/26

    Thu

    West Side Story
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $108+
  • 6/25/26

    Thu

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $155+
  • 6/26/26

    Fri

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $108+
  • 6/27/26

    Sat

    West Side Story
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $108+
  • 6/27/26

    Sat

    West Side Story
    7:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $168+
  • 6/28/26

    Sun

    West Side Story
    1:30 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $168+
  • 6/28/26

    Sun

    West Side Story
    7:00 PMPaper Mill PlayhouseMillburn, NJ
    FROM $108+

Verified Tickets at the Best Prices.100% Gametime Guaranteed.

100% Gametime Guaranteed.

  • Lowest Price Guarantee
  • Event Cancellation Protection
  • On-Time Ticket Delivery